The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit has ruled against a number of local business owners in their high-profile lawsuit against local discovery service Yelp this week, stating that there is no conclusive evidence that the site manufactures reviews to cause harm to businesses that do not advertise with the site.
In the Levitt v. Yelp suit, four small businesses in the State of California allege that Yelp intentionally removed positive reviews from their pages when they opted not to advertise with the service. They also claim that Yelp manufactured negative reviews as retribution for declining or discontinuing ad services.
The three judge panel presiding ruled that there was no evidence that Yelp authored negative reviews. And though the court notes that Yelp does use automated software to hide certain reviews it believes are fake and has allowed businesses to “highlight” positive reviews in the past, none of these actions rise to a the level of extortion. Even if Yelp does intentionally hide positive reviews to put the screws to businesses, the court says, it was within its legal right to do so.
“Yelp’s manipulation of user reviews, assuming it occurred, was not wrongful use of economic fear,” writes Judge Marsha Berzon in her opinion (PDF).
Yelp applauded the ruling, which upholds a similar ruling issued by a lower court.
“We are obviously happy that the Court reached the right result, and saw through these thin attempts by a few businesses and their lawyers to disparage Yelp and draw attention away from their own occasional negative review,” the company said in a blog post.
From James Lewis on September 04, 2014 :: 1:19 pm
Yelp is here to stay and businesses need to stop wasting money through lawsuits and begin using the site in a effective manner for their business benefit. I’m not a fan of yelp but I understand that this is where many of my customers are so I have to participate. Yelp just issued a new round of consumer alerts today (http://www.webpronews.com/yelp-busts-businesses-by-using-their-private-messages-as-evidence-of-fake-reviews-2014-09). I don’t understand why businesses do stuff like that, it is common sense that Yelp will monitor their internal messaging for this behavior. Why don’t businesses just ask their customers for reviews, give out post cards, display the stickers or use a solution like http://thereviewsolution.com/, http://business.trustpilot.com/ or https://www.demandforce.com/ there are so many ways of generating reviews online these days, why go black hat and violate their TOS?
Reply